Save

generator/solo/composer.py

@@ -31,11 +31,14 @@ def compose(analysis, measures, part, end, *, scales, sequences, rhythms, initia
       raise ValueError(f'{part} solo, source measure {choice.span.source_measure}, beat {choice.span.beat}, {generator.harmony.symbol(choice.span.chord)}: No exact match within the permitted catalog')
   from generator.solo import leads
   context = context if context is not None else generator.solo.realization.SearchContext()
+  context.expressions_enabled = enclosures_enabled
   options = leads.solo_options(analysis, measures, part, end, choices, sequences, rhythms, context, stage, mode)
   result = options[0][1]
   result.diagnostics['strict_composition_seconds'] = time.monotonic()-started
   from generator.solo import expressions
-  result = expressions.refine(result,enclosures_enabled and stage=='elaborated' and mode=='thematic')
+  if mode!='thematic':result = expressions.refine(result,False)
+  result.diagnostics['enclosures_enabled']=enclosures_enabled
+  result.diagnostics['expressions_selected']=[e.kind for p in result.phrases for e in p.draft.expressions]
   validate(result)
   return result
 

generator/solo/expressions.py

@@ -89,6 +89,17 @@ def validate(notes,contracts,harmony):
       last=c.events[-1]
       if rule.get('resolve'):
         if target is last or not 0<=target.start-last.end<=F(vocabulary.data('harmony')['resolution_gap']) or not 0<abs(target.pitch.number()-last.pitch.number())<=2 or target.pitch.number()%12 not in harmony.members(target.start,target.end):return {},c.id+': unresolved color'
+    elif c.kind=='suspension':
+      rule=next((r for r in vocabulary.data('harmony').get('suspensions',[]) if r['id']==c.rule),None)
+      if not rule or len(c.events)!=1 or c.boundary is None:return {},c.id+': unsupported suspension'
+      held,=c.events
+      if not held.start<=c.boundary-F(rule['preparation'])<c.boundary<held.end:
+        return {},c.id+': insufficient sounding preparation'
+      if held.pitch.number()%12 not in harmony.members(held.start,c.boundary):return {},c.id+': nonchordal preparation'
+      if held.end-c.boundary>F(rule['max_delay']) or target.start!=held.end or target.pitch.number()-held.pitch.number() not in rule['steps']:
+        return {},c.id+': missed suspension resolution'
+      if target.pitch.number()%12 not in harmony.members(target.start,target.end):return {},c.id+': invalid suspension target'
+      if held.pitch.number()%12 not in types.permitted(harmony.choices,held.start,held.end):return {},c.id+': suspension outside mapped collections'
     elif c.kind=='anticipation':
       if c.rule!='early_chord_tone' or len(c.events)!=1 or c.target!=c.events[0] or span.start!=c.boundary:
         return {},c.id+': unknown anticipation or non-boundary target'
@@ -116,6 +127,34 @@ def validate(notes,contracts,harmony):
   return approved,''
 
 
+def validate_frontier(notes,contracts,harmony,until,complete):
+  """Validate heard prefixes and bounded future obligations separately.
+
+  Future contract events are used ONLY to establish rule feasibility. They do
+  not count as heard resolution; the contract stays pending until its entire
+  target hold is present. Missing past events and expired deadlines fail.
+  """
+  if complete:
+    approved,error=validate(notes,contracts,harmony)
+    return approved,(),error
+  actual={n.event_id:n for n in notes};future=dict(actual);pending=[]
+  for c in contracts:
+    required=tuple(dict.fromkeys((*c.events,c.target,*((c.preparation,) if c.preparation else ()))))
+    incomplete=False
+    for expected in required:
+      heard=actual.get(expected.event_id)
+      if expected.start>=until:
+        future[expected.event_id]=expected;incomplete=True
+      elif heard and heard.pitch==expected.pitch and heard.start==expected.start and heard.end==min(until,expected.end):
+        future[expected.event_id]=expected
+        incomplete |= heard.end<expected.end
+      elif not heard or (heard.start,heard.end,heard.pitch)!=(expected.start,expected.end,expected.pitch):
+        return {},(),c.id+': missing/changed event before resolution deadline'
+    if incomplete:pending.append(c)
+  approved,error=validate(tuple(sorted(future.values(),key=lambda n:(n.start,n.event_id))),contracts,harmony)
+  return {key:c for key,c in approved.items() if key in actual},tuple(pending),error
+
+
 def proposals(phrase,harmony):
   draft=phrase.draft
   if not draft or any(n.continuation for n in draft.notes):return
@@ -160,6 +199,73 @@ def proposals(phrase,harmony):
     if actual:
       actual=tuple(n if a.event_id==target.event_id else a for a in actual)
       yield actual,types.ExpressionContract(target.event_id+':anticipate','anticipation','early_chord_tone',(n,),n,harmony.at(target.start).chord,boundary=target.start)
+  for i,(before,target) in enumerate(zip(notes,notes[1:])):
+    boundary=target.start
+    if before.end!=boundary or boundary not in {s.start for s in harmony.spans}:continue
+    if not enclosures.editable(draft,before.start,target.end):continue
+    for rule in vocabulary.data('harmony').get('suspensions',[]):
+      delay=min(F(1,2),F(rule['max_delay']))
+      if target.end<=boundary+delay:continue
+      held=dataclasses.replace(before,end=boundary+delay,role='suspension')
+      resolved=dataclasses.replace(target,start=boundary+delay)
+      yield (*notes[:i],held,resolved,*notes[i+2:]),types.ExpressionContract(before.event_id+':suspend',
+        'suspension',rule['id'],(held,),resolved,harmony.at(boundary).chord,boundary=boundary)
+
+
+def joint_candidates(phrases,incoming,harmony,tempo,context,*,bar=F(4)):
+  """Expression alternatives compete BEFORE complete-phrase selection.
+
+  This rewrites provisional gestures, never the selected chorus. The direct
+  realization remains available and every alternative uses the same evaluator.
+  """
+  from generator.solo import realization, sequences, phrasing, groups
+  result=list(phrases)
+  trace=context.diagnostics.setdefault('expression_operations',{})
+  for phrase in phrases:
+    proposed={}
+    for actual,c in proposals(phrase,harmony):
+      counts=trace.setdefault(c.kind,dict(proposed=0,valid=0,retained=0,rejected_by_rule=0))
+      counts['proposed']+=1
+      old_pattern=tuple((n.start-phrase.plan.start,n.end-phrase.plan.start) for n in phrase.draft.notes)
+      new_pattern=tuple((n.start-phrase.plan.start,n.end-phrase.plan.start) for n in actual)
+      if groups.valid(old_pattern) and not groups.valid(new_pattern):
+        counts['rejected_by_rule']+=1;continue
+      if not drafts.contract_valid(phrase.draft,actual)[0]:
+        counts['rejected_by_rule']+=1;continue
+      checked=harmony.evaluate(actual,until=phrase.plan.end,complete=True,expressions=(c,))
+      if not checked.valid:
+        counts['rejected_by_rule']+=1;continue
+      counts['valid']+=1
+      prior=next((n for n in reversed(actual) if n.end<=c.events[0].start),None)
+      join=abs(prior.pitch.number()-c.events[0].pitch.number()) if prior else 0
+      rank=max(0,join-5)+bool(prior and prior.pitch==c.events[0].pitch)
+      proposed.setdefault(c.kind,[]).append((rank,actual,c))
+    # One representative per treatment kind, then a bounded second sweep.
+    options=sequences.diverse([v for values in proposed.values() for v in values],
+      lambda v:(v[0],policy.stable_rank(phrase.plan.seed,v[2].id)),lambda v:v[2].kind,8)
+    for _,actual,c in options:
+      transforms=tuple(dataclasses.replace(t,
+        events=tuple(n.event_id for n in actual if t.start<=n.start<t.end),
+        rhythm=tuple((n.start-t.start,n.end-t.start) for n in actual if t.start<=n.start<t.end))
+        for t in phrase.draft.transformations)
+      changed=dataclasses.replace(phrase.draft,id=phrase.draft.id+':'+c.rule,
+        notes=actual,expressions=(c,),transformations=transforms)
+      candidate=realization.checked_phrase(phrase.plan,changed,actual,incoming.treatments,incoming,harmony,tempo,phrase.edits)
+      if candidate is None:continue
+      trace[c.kind]['retained']+=1
+      state=dataclasses.replace(phrase.state,notes=candidate.state.notes,last=candidate.state.last,
+        motifs=candidate.state.motifs,travel=candidate.state.travel)
+      history=incoming.history
+      for t in transforms:
+        ns=tuple(n for n in actual if n.event_id in t.events)
+        if ns:history=phrasing.remember(history,phrasing.heard(ns,t.operation,bar=bar),bar)
+      state=dataclasses.replace(state,history=history)
+      kept_routes=tuple(r for r in phrase.routes if all(any((n.event_id,n.start,n.end,n.pitch)==
+        (a.event_id,a.start,a.end,a.pitch) for a in actual) for n in r.notes))
+      original=dataclasses.replace(phrase.draft,notes=tuple(n for d in phrase.decisions for n in d.notes))
+      result.append(dataclasses.replace(candidate,state=state,initial=phrase.initial,
+        refined=phrase.refined,before_rhythm=phrase.before_rhythm,before_enclosure=original,routes=kept_routes))
+  return result
 
 
 def refine(solo,enabled=True):

generator/solo/gesture_rhythm.py

@@ -4,7 +4,44 @@ from __future__ import annotations
 import dataclasses
 from fractions import Fraction as F
 
-from generator.solo import drafts, harmonic, types
+from generator.solo import drafts, harmonic, types, groups
+
+
+def join_variants(draft,harmony,library):
+  """Recompose both sides of an editable internal join as one complete route.
+
+  Keep endpoints and exact span. A provisional held tail can reopen into two
+  binary attacks; a committed hold or identifying event is never consumed.
+  Alternatives are returned to the authoritative phrase evaluator.
+  """
+  from generator.solo import routes, policy
+  fixed=set(draft.protected)|set(draft.structural)|{e for f in draft.features for e in f.events}
+  produced=0
+  for join in (t.start for t in draft.transformations[1:]):
+    inside=tuple(n for n in draft.notes if join-2<=n.start and n.end<=join+2)
+    if len(inside)<3 or any(n.event_id in fixed or n.role=='quote' for n in inside[1:-1]):continue
+    if any(t.start<inside[-1].end and t.end>inside[0].start for t in draft.sustained_tails):continue
+    pattern=tuple((n.start-inside[0].start,n.end-inside[0].start) for n in inside)
+    if not groups.valid(pattern):continue
+    alternatives=[inside]
+    for i,n in enumerate(inside[1:-1],1):
+      if n.end==join and n.end-n.start>=1 and (n.start*2).denominator==1:
+        cut=n.end-F(1,2)
+        alternatives.append((*inside[:i],dataclasses.replace(n,end=cut),
+          dataclasses.replace(n,start=cut,event_id=n.event_id+':extend'),*inside[i+1:]))
+        break
+    for template in alternatives:
+      for route in routes.candidates(template,{template[-1].event_id},harmony,library,harmony.profile.register,'two-sided join'):
+        if route.notes==inside:continue
+        actual=tuple(n for n in draft.notes if n.end<=inside[0].start)+route.notes+tuple(n for n in draft.notes if n.start>=inside[-1].end)
+        if not drafts.contract_valid(draft,actual)[0] or not harmony.evaluate(actual,until=draft.end,complete=True).valid:continue
+        transforms=tuple(dataclasses.replace(t,events=tuple(n.event_id for n in actual if t.start<=n.start<t.end),
+          rhythm=tuple((n.start-t.start,n.end-t.start) for n in actual if t.start<=n.start<t.end)) for t in draft.transformations)
+        changed=dataclasses.replace(draft,id=draft.id+':join:'+route.id,notes=actual,transformations=transforms)
+        yield changed,types.DraftEdit('two_sided_join',inside[0].start,inside[-1].end,
+          tuple(n.event_id for n in inside),tuple(n.event_id for n in route.notes),'complete route over both sides; endpoints and contracts preserved'),route
+        produced+=1
+        if produced>=policy.DEFAULT.join_alternatives:return
 
 
 def fragmentation(notes):
@@ -71,6 +108,7 @@ def revise(draft, harmony, treatments=()):
       if len(proposals)>=8: break
     valid=[]
     for actual in proposals[:8]:
+      if not groups.valid(tuple((n.start-draft.start,n.end-draft.start) for n in actual)):continue
       if fragmentation(actual)>=fragmentation(notes): continue
       if not drafts.contract_valid(draft,actual)[0]: continue
       if not harmony.evaluate(actual,treatments,until=draft.end,complete=True).valid: continue

generator/solo/groups.py

@@ -0,0 +1,68 @@
+"""Exact rhythmic groups for generated material; imported music is not quantized.
+
+Binary boundaries may be displaced together. Tuplet runs must return to their
+entry subdivision phase before binary material resumes. A search boundary is
+not a rhythmic boundary and must not be used to clip a group.
+"""
+from __future__ import annotations
+import dataclasses
+from fractions import Fraction as F
+
+
+@dataclasses.dataclass(frozen=True)
+class RhythmGroup:
+  start: F
+  end: F
+  family: str
+  events: tuple[tuple[F, F], ...]
+  displacement: F = F()
+  source: str = ''
+
+
+def describe(pattern, *, origin=F(), source='', imported=False):
+  if not pattern:return ()
+  if imported:
+    return (RhythmGroup(origin, origin+pattern[-1][1], 'source', pattern, source=source),)
+  result=[]; i=0
+  while i<len(pattern):
+    a,b=pattern[i]
+    if b<=a or i and a<pattern[i-1][1]:raise ValueError('overlapping rhythm group')
+    # A complete ternary figure can be intentionally displaced on an eighth.
+    if (b-a).denominator%3==0:
+      if (a*2).denominator!=1:raise ValueError('unexplained tuplet entry phase')
+      start=i; cursor=a
+      while i<len(pattern):
+        x,y=pattern[i]
+        if x!=cursor or (y-x).denominator not in (3,6):break
+        cursor=y;i+=1
+        if (cursor-a).denominator==1:break
+      if i==start or (cursor-a).denominator!=1:
+        raise ValueError('incomplete tuplet group')
+      group=pattern[start:i]
+      result.append(RhythmGroup(origin+a,origin+cursor,'triplet',group,a%1,source))
+    else:
+      if (a*4).denominator!=1 or (b*4).denominator!=1:
+        raise ValueError('unexplained binary subdivision phase')
+      family='sixteenth' if (a*2).denominator!=1 or (b*2).denominator!=1 else 'binary'
+      result.append(RhythmGroup(origin+a,origin+b,family,((a,b),),a%1,source));i+=1
+  return tuple(result)
+
+
+def valid(pattern):
+  try:describe(pattern);return True
+  except ValueError:return False
+
+
+def signature(notes):
+  """Translation-invariant duration, inter-onset and rest vocabulary."""
+  return tuple((n.end-n.start, notes[i+1].start-n.end if i+1<len(notes) else F())
+    for i,n in enumerate(notes))
+
+
+def broaden(pattern, arrival, release):
+  """Reopen an editable binary tail; never slice a tuplet or inherit its phase."""
+  if (arrival*2).denominator!=1 or (release*2).denominator!=1:return ()
+  for group in describe(pattern):
+    if group.family=='triplet' and group.start<arrival<group.end:return ()
+  result=tuple((a,min(b,arrival)) for a,b in pattern if a<arrival)+((arrival,release),)
+  return result if valid(result) else ()

generator/solo/harmonic.py

@@ -150,15 +150,15 @@ class Harmony:
 
   def evaluate(self, notes, treatments=(), *, until=None, complete=False, enclosures=(), expressions=()):
     notes = generator.solo.types.sounding_notes(notes)
-    from generator.solo.expressions import validate
-    permissions, expression_error = validate(notes, expressions, self)
-    if expression_error:
-      return Result(False, 0, error=expression_error)
+    from generator.solo.expressions import validate_frontier
+    explicit_frontier=until is not None
     until = until if until is not None else max((n.end for n in notes), default=fractions.Fraction())
+    permissions, expression_pending, expression_error = validate_frontier(notes,expressions,self,until,complete or not explicit_frontier)
+    if expression_error:return Result(False,0,error=expression_error)
     ornaments, error = self.enclosure_events(notes, enclosures, until) if enclosures else ({}, '')
     if error:
       return Result(False, 0, error=error)
-    pending, valid_contracts = [], []
+    pending, valid_contracts = list(expression_pending), []
     for treatment in treatments:
       if treatment.start >= until:
         continue

generator/solo/leads.py

@@ -27,13 +27,17 @@ def shift(notes, octave):
 
 
 def available(harmony, start, end, *, members=False):
-  span = harmony.at(start)
-  allowed = types.permitted(harmony.choices, start, end)
-  if members:
-    allowed &= harmony.members(start, end)
-  if not span or not span.scale:
-    return ()
-  return tuple(p for i in range(-35, 28) if harmony.profile.register[0] <= (p := types.scale_pitch(span.scale, i)).number() <= harmony.profile.register[1] and p.number()%12 in allowed and placement.positions(p.number(),harmony.profile))
+  if not hasattr(harmony,'available_pitches'):harmony.available_pitches={}
+  span=harmony.at(start)
+  allowed=types.permitted(harmony.choices,start,end)
+  if members:allowed &= harmony.members(start,end)
+  if not span or not span.scale:return ()
+  key=(span.scale,allowed,harmony.profile)
+  if key not in harmony.available_pitches:
+    harmony.available_pitches[key]=tuple(p for i in range(-35,28)
+      if harmony.profile.register[0]<=(p:=types.scale_pitch(span.scale,i)).number()<=harmony.profile.register[1]
+      and p.number()%12 in allowed and placement.positions(p.number(),harmony.profile))
+  return harmony.available_pitches[key]
 
 
 def adapt(notes, harmony):
@@ -350,6 +354,7 @@ def thematic_options(analysis,measures,part,end,choices,library,rhythms,context,
         if elapsed>start:
           meter=measure['time_signature'];break
       bar=F(meter.split('/')[0])*4/int(meter.split('/')[1])
+      harmony.bar=bar
       for source in sources:
         key=('phrasing',source,incoming,part,end,stage,seed,id(library),id(rhythms),policy.DEFAULT,harmony.profile)
         if key in context.results:
@@ -367,11 +372,10 @@ def thematic_options(analysis,measures,part,end,choices,library,rhythms,context,
           context.results[key]=pool
         context.diagnostics.setdefault('source_candidate_pools',{}).setdefault(source.id,[]).extend(
           {'id':p.draft.id,'score':p.score,'attacks':len(p.draft.notes),'theme':p.state.home.id if p.state.home else None,
-           'ending':str(p.anchors[-1].duration) if p.anchors else None,'returns':len(p.state.returns)} for p in pool)
+           'ending':str(p.anchors[-1].duration) if p.anchors else None,'returns':len(p.state.returns),'evaluation':dataclasses.asdict(p.evaluation) if p.evaluation else None} for p in pool)
         for candidate in pool:
           span=float((source.end-source.start)/end)
-          total=cost+span*(candidate.score+phrasing.endpoint_cost(source.end,start,end,incoming.closures,harmony,bar))
-          total+=transition(history[-1] if history else None,candidate)
+          total=cost+span*candidate.score
           following.append((total,(*history,candidate)))
         if not pool:failures.append(f'{source.id}: planned sustained destination, feature or incoming continuation')
     if not following:
@@ -385,7 +389,7 @@ def thematic_options(analysis,measures,part,end,choices,library,rhythms,context,
   finished=[(cost,history) for cost,history in states if history[-1].plan.end==end]
   if not finished:raise realization.SearchExhausted(f'{part}: phrase-boundary search budget exhausted; not proof of incompatibility')
   return tuple((rank((cost,phrases))[0],types.Solo(part,choices,phrases,analysis.tempo,end,
-    {**context.diagnostics,'construction':'thematic_recomposition','policy':policy.describe()['fingerprint']},
+    {**context.diagnostics,'selection_total':rank((cost,phrases))[0], 'selection_scope':'duration-weighted complete phrase evaluations; partial frontiers use elapsed-duration rates', 'construction':'thematic_recomposition','policy':policy.describe()['fingerprint']},
     tuple(types.MelodicPassagePlan(p.plan.passage_id,p.plan.start,p.plan.end,(p.plan.id,),seed) for p in phrases),harmony.profile)) for cost,phrases in finished)
 
 

generator/solo/phrasing.py

@@ -57,9 +57,13 @@ def register_goal(incoming, part, fallback, profile=None):
   if profile and profile.reference is not None:
     recent = [p for h in incoming.history[-2:] for _,_,p in h.events]
     center = round(sum(recent)/len(recent)) if recent else profile.reference
-    trajectory=generator.vocabulary.role(part+'_solo').get('register_motion',[0,4,-3,0])
-    phase=min(len(trajectory)-1,incoming.closures%len(trajectory))
-    goal=profile.reference+trajectory[phase]
+    # Follow a whole-gesture excursion with a possible return, not an
+    # instrument-specific octave or a repeating register cycle.
+    if center>profile.reference+7:goal=profile.reference
+    elif center<profile.reference-7:goal=profile.reference
+    else:
+      motion=incoming.direction*4 if incoming.home else 0
+      goal=profile.reference+motion
     return max(profile.register[0]+3,min(profile.register[1]-3,round((center+goal)/2)))
   recent = [p for h in incoming.history[-2:] for _,_,p in h.events]
   if not recent:
@@ -127,7 +131,7 @@ def endings(source, incoming, part, harmony, bar, *, limit=8, final=False):
       for pitch in available(harmony,arrival,arrival+hold,members=True):
         if abs(pitch.number()-goal)>12:continue
         anchor=types.Anchor(f'{source.id}:close:{arrival}:{pitch.number()}',arrival,arrival,pitch,
-          harmony.members(arrival,arrival+hold),harmony.profile.register,hold,'terminal',harmony.at(arrival).chord,
+          harmony.members(arrival,arrival+hold),harmony.profile.register,hold,'terminal' if final or ending_effect(arrival,harmony)=='cadential_arrival' else 'intermediate',harmony.at(arrival).chord,
           hold_until=arrival+hold,effect=ending_effect(arrival,harmony,final))
         cadence=sum(h.ending==(pitch.number()%12,arrival%bar,hold) for h in incoming.history)
         rank=harmony.profile.cost(pitch.number())+destination_cost(pitch,arrival,arrival+hold,harmony,incoming,goal,True)+.16*min(2,cadence)+.035*abs(float(hold)-3)
@@ -145,6 +149,7 @@ def appearance_cost(operation, incoming, start, end):
 
 
 def activity(source, ending):
+  if ending is None:return (types.ActivitySpan(source.start,source.end,'active',F(5,4),F()),)
   spans=[]
   if ending.earliest>source.start:
     spans.append(types.ActivitySpan(source.start,ending.earliest,'active',F(5,4),F()))
@@ -154,17 +159,6 @@ def activity(source, ending):
   return tuple(spans)
 
 
-def evaluate(notes, incoming, harmony, start, end, bar):
-  """Final musical cost uses a complete sounding phrase, never cell totals."""
-  notes=types.sounding_notes(notes)
-  checked=harmony.evaluate(notes,until=end,complete=True)
-  if not checked.valid or not notes:return float('inf')
-  density=4*len(notes)/float(end-start)
-  entry=max(0,abs(notes[0].pitch.number()-incoming.last.pitch.number())-5)/12 if incoming.last else 0.
-  leaps=sum(max(0,abs(b.pitch.number()-a.pitch.number())-5)/12 for a,b in zip(notes,notes[1:]))/max(1,len(notes)-1)
-  history_cost=repetition(heard(notes,'develop'),incoming.history,bar)
-  return harmony.profile.cost(profiles.weighted_center(notes))+2*checked.exposure+entry+leaps+.8*history_cost
-
 
 @functools.lru_cache(maxsize=512)
 def defining_members(symbol):

generator/solo/policy.py

@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ class Policy:
   enclosure_routes: int = 4
   enclosure_frontier: int = 8
   enclosure_max_per_32_bars: int = 4
-  composition_version: str = 'purposeful-phrases-2'
+  composition_version: str = 'joint-gestures-1'
 
 # Preserve the former default root seeds while decoupling them from policy edits.
 SEED_NAMESPACE = 'a85abb240d7cfa9d054375b654bcb5c23c746201fd4aed7acf81cb3f4ee720e1'

generator/solo/profiles.py

@@ -47,10 +47,9 @@ def for_part(part, analysis=None):
   strings = (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)
   if analysis is None or not analysis.melody:
     return Instrument(part, strings)
-  # Analysis contains the prepared concert source. Electric melody is written
-  # two octaves up and sounds one down (parts.build_measure), hence +12.
-  # Use the source voice, never the highest added harmonization voice.
-  shift = generator.vocabulary.role(part + '_solo').get('register_offset', 12 if part == 'electric' else 0)
-  notes = tuple(n for n in analysis.melody if n.end > analysis.body_offset)
-  return Instrument(part, strings, weighted_center(notes) + shift,
-    (min(n.pitch.number() for n in notes) + shift, max(n.pitch.number() for n in notes) + shift))
+  # Source identity is independent of sounding register. Roles have soft,
+  # overlapping centers; all legal positions remain available to both guitars.
+  center=generator.vocabulary.role(part+'_solo').get('register_center',57 if part=='acoustic' else 62)
+  notes=tuple(n for n in analysis.melody if n.end>analysis.body_offset)
+  return Instrument(part,strings,center,
+    (min(n.pitch.number() for n in notes),max(n.pitch.number() for n in notes)))

generator/solo/realization.py

@@ -510,39 +510,45 @@ def checked_phrase(plan, draft, notes, contracts, incoming, harmony, tempo, edit
   except ValueError:
     return None
   complete = plan.end == (plan.passage_end or plan.end)
-  checked = harmony.evaluate(canonical, contracts, until=plan.end, complete=complete, enclosures=draft.enclosures)
+  checked = harmony.evaluate(canonical, contracts, until=plan.end, complete=complete, enclosures=draft.enclosures, expressions=draft.expressions)
   valid, _ = generator.solo.harmonic.anchors_valid(draft.anchors, canonical, plan.end, complete=complete, closure=plan.closure)
   if not checked.valid or not valid or not target_ok(notes, plan.target):
     return None
   shared = bool(plan.passage_id and incoming.passage_id == plan.passage_id)
   score_notes = canonical if shared or notes and notes[0].continuation else generator.solo.drafts.local_sounding(notes)
-  evaluation_key = (plan, draft.anchors)
-  if evaluation_key not in harmony.evaluations:
-    harmony.evaluations[evaluation_key] = generator.solo.scoring.Evaluation(evaluation_plan(plan, draft.anchors), harmony.choices, plan.end)
-  evaluation = harmony.evaluations[evaluation_key]
-  if not evaluation.feasible(score_notes):
-    return None
-  features = evaluation.features(score_notes, previous=incoming.last if not shared else None, movement=travel + (incoming.travel if shared else 0))
-  features.update(generator.solo.drafts.relationship_features(draft, notes))
-  if draft.lead_identity or draft.source_phrase:
-    supported = {e for feature in draft.features for e in feature.events}
-    motions = [(a, b) for a, b in zip(notes, notes[1:]) if not (a.event_id in supported and b.event_id in supported)]
-    features['contour'] = sum(min(1, max(0, abs(b.pitch.number() - a.pitch.number()) - 5) / 12) for a, b in motions) / max(1, len(motions))
-  # Fidelity is checked against explicit transformed identities, not against
-  # the source head as one undifferentiated phrase-long quotation.
-  features.pop('fidelity', None)
-  features['harmonic_exposure'] = checked.exposure
-  intended_repeats = 0
-  if draft.home:
-    reference = draft.home.notes
-    for transform in draft.transformations:
-      actual = tuple(n for n in notes if n.event_id in transform.events)
-      for i, (a, b, c) in enumerate(zip(actual, actual[1:], actual[2:])):
-        expected = tuple(reference[j % len(reference)].pitch for j in (i, i + 1, i + 2)) if reference else ()
-        if a.pitch == b.pitch == c.pitch and len(expected) == 3 and expected[0] == expected[1] == expected[2]:
-          intended_repeats += 1
-  features['repetition'] = max(0, features['repetition'] - intended_repeats / max(1, len(score_notes) - 2))
-  score = generator.solo.scoring.value(features)
+  musical = None
+  if plan.treatment == 'thematic_recomposition':
+    musical = generator.solo.scoring.musical(plan,draft,notes,incoming,harmony,travel=travel)
+    if not musical.valid:return None
+    score = musical.total
+  else:
+    evaluation_key = (plan, draft.anchors)
+    if evaluation_key not in harmony.evaluations:
+      harmony.evaluations[evaluation_key] = generator.solo.scoring.Evaluation(evaluation_plan(plan, draft.anchors), harmony.choices, plan.end)
+    evaluation = harmony.evaluations[evaluation_key]
+    if not evaluation.feasible(score_notes):
+      return None
+    features = evaluation.features(score_notes, previous=incoming.last if not shared else None, movement=travel + (incoming.travel if shared else 0))
+    features.update(generator.solo.drafts.relationship_features(draft, notes))
+    if draft.lead_identity or draft.source_phrase:
+      supported = {e for feature in draft.features for e in feature.events}
+      motions = [(a, b) for a, b in zip(notes, notes[1:]) if not (a.event_id in supported and b.event_id in supported)]
+      features['contour'] = sum(min(1, max(0, abs(b.pitch.number() - a.pitch.number()) - 5) / 12) for a, b in motions) / max(1, len(motions))
+    # Fidelity is checked against explicit transformed identities, not against
+    # the source head as one undifferentiated phrase-long quotation.
+    features.pop('fidelity', None)
+    features['harmonic_exposure'] = checked.exposure
+    intended_repeats = 0
+    if draft.home:
+      reference = draft.home.notes
+      for transform in draft.transformations:
+        actual = tuple(n for n in notes if n.event_id in transform.events)
+        for i, (a, b, c) in enumerate(zip(actual, actual[1:], actual[2:])):
+          expected = tuple(reference[j % len(reference)].pitch for j in (i, i + 1, i + 2)) if reference else ()
+          if a.pitch == b.pitch == c.pitch and len(expected) == 3 and expected[0] == expected[1] == expected[2]:
+            intended_repeats += 1
+    features['repetition'] = max(0, features['repetition'] - intended_repeats / max(1, len(score_notes) - 2))
+    score = generator.solo.scoring.value(features)
   motifs = list(incoming.motifs) if shared else []
   decisions = []
   for transform in draft.transformations:
@@ -568,7 +574,7 @@ def checked_phrase(plan, draft, notes, contracts, incoming, harmony, tempo, edit
     (notes[-1].pitch.number() > notes[0].pitch.number()) - (notes[-1].pitch.number() < notes[0].pitch.number()) if notes else incoming.direction,
     last, 0, (), travel + (incoming.travel if shared else 0), home, motifs[-1] if motifs else incoming.development, themes, draft.anchors, plan.ending)
   actual_plan = dataclasses.replace(plan, relationship=draft.relationship)
-  return generator.solo.types.Phrase(actual_plan, tuple(decisions), score, state, draft.anchors, draft, edits)
+  return generator.solo.types.Phrase(actual_plan, tuple(decisions), score, state, draft.anchors, draft, edits, evaluation=musical)
 
 def legacy_target_plan(plan, choices):
   if not plan.target or plan.anchor_options:

generator/solo/report.py

@@ -16,13 +16,13 @@ import generator.solo.similarity
 import generator.solo.features
 import generator.solo.placement
 
-def describe(solo: generator.solo.types.Solo, scales, measure_offset=0, time_offset=0) -> str:
+def describe(solo: generator.solo.types.Solo, scales, measure_offset=0, time_offset=0, *, detail=None) -> str:
   region = generator.scales.timeline.Solo(time_offset, time_offset + solo.end, solo.part.capitalize() + ' Solo')
   positioned = tuple(dataclasses.replace(c, span=dataclasses.replace(c.span, start=c.span.start + time_offset, end=c.span.end + time_offset, measure=c.span.measure + measure_offset)) for c in solo.choices)
   lines = [generator.scales.report.passage(solo.part, region, positioned, scales), f'Phrase composition: {solo.part}', f'Placement reference tempo: {solo.tempo} quarter notes/minute. Runtime tempo changes are not a comfort guarantee.', 'Times below are quarter-note offsets from the start of this solo; pitches are sounding.']
   if solo.diagnostics:
-    lines.append('Composition diagnostics: ' + json.dumps({k: v for k, v in solo.diagnostics.items() if not k.endswith('_seconds')}, sort_keys=True))
-  detail = structure(solo)
+    lines.append('Composition diagnostics: ' + json.dumps({k: v for k, v in solo.diagnostics.items() if not k.endswith('_seconds')}, sort_keys=True,default=str))
+  detail = structure(solo) if detail is None else detail
   lines.append("Sustained phrasing: " + json.dumps(detail["phrasing"], sort_keys=True))
   for passage in detail['passages']:
     lines.append(f"Melodic passage {passage['id']}: {passage['start']}-{passage['end']}; phrases {', '.join(passage['phrases'])}")
@@ -126,9 +126,15 @@ def structure(solo):
       entry['head_comparison_elaborated']=generator.solo.similarity.compare(tuple(n for d in phrase.decisions for n in d.notes),local_source)
       if phrase.state and phrase.state.home:
         entry['theme_relationship']=generator.solo.features.relationship(phrase.refined.notes,phrase.state.home)
+    entry['evaluation'] = rational(dataclasses.asdict(phrase.evaluation)) if phrase.evaluation else None
+    from generator.solo import groups
+    try:
+      entry['rhythm_groups']=rational([dataclasses.asdict(g) for g in groups.describe(tuple((n.start-phrase.plan.start,n.end-phrase.plan.start) for n in phrase.draft.notes),origin=phrase.plan.start)]) if phrase.draft else []
+    except ValueError as error:
+      entry['rhythm_groups']=[{'family':'source','reason':str(error)}]
     entry['score'] = phrase.score
     phrases.append(entry)
-  return {'instrument_profile': rational(dataclasses.asdict(solo.profile)) if solo.profile else None, 'phrasing': phrasing_report(solo), 'source_comparison': {stage:generator.solo.similarity.compare(tuple(n for p in solo.phrases for n in (p.refined.notes if stage=='plain' and p.refined else tuple(n for d in p.decisions for n in d.notes))),tuple(n for p in solo.phrases if p.initial for n in p.initial.notes)) for stage in ('plain','elaborated')}, 'fretboard': fretboard_report(solo), 'passages': [{'id': p.id, 'start': str(p.start), 'end': str(p.end), 'phrases': list(p.phrase_ids), 'seed': p.seed} for p in solo.passages], 'phrases': phrases, 'expressions': rational([dataclasses.asdict(e) for e in expressions]), 'enclosures': rational([dataclasses.asdict(e) for e in enclosures]), 'harmonic_roles': harmony.describe(solo.notes(), contracts,enclosures,expressions), 'harmonic_exposure': checked.exposure, 'harmonic_valid': checked.valid, 'harmonic_error': checked.error, 'unresolved_treatments': rational([dataclasses.asdict(t) for t in checked.pending]), 'treatments': rational([dataclasses.asdict(t) for t in contracts])}
+  return {'schema':'composer-report-2','selection_trace':rational({k:v for k,v in solo.diagnostics.items() if not k.endswith('_seconds')}), 'instrument_profile': rational(dataclasses.asdict(solo.profile)) if solo.profile else None, 'phrasing': phrasing_report(solo), 'source_comparison': {stage:generator.solo.similarity.compare(tuple(n for p in solo.phrases for n in (p.refined.notes if stage=='plain' and p.refined else tuple(n for d in p.decisions for n in d.notes))),tuple(n for p in solo.phrases if p.initial for n in p.initial.notes)) for stage in ('plain','elaborated')}, 'fretboard': fretboard_report(solo), 'passages': [{'id': p.id, 'start': str(p.start), 'end': str(p.end), 'phrases': list(p.phrase_ids), 'seed': p.seed} for p in solo.passages], 'phrases': phrases, 'expressions': rational([dataclasses.asdict(e) for e in expressions]), 'enclosures': rational([dataclasses.asdict(e) for e in enclosures]), 'harmonic_roles': harmony.describe(solo.notes(), contracts,enclosures,expressions), 'harmonic_exposure': checked.exposure, 'harmonic_valid': checked.valid, 'harmonic_error': checked.error, 'unresolved_treatments': rational([dataclasses.asdict(t) for t in checked.pending]), 'treatments': rational([dataclasses.asdict(t) for t in contracts])}
 
 
 def phrasing_report(solo):

generator/solo/routes.py

@@ -89,7 +89,7 @@ def _candidates(notes, fixed, harmony, library, register, purpose='connect'):
   if not span or not span.scale:
     return ()
   contexts=tuple((harmony.at(n.start).scale if harmony.at(n.start) else None,
-    types.permitted(harmony.choices,n.start,n.end),
+    types.permitted(harmony.choices,n.start,n.end) & (harmony.members(n.start,n.end) if n.end-n.start>=2 else frozenset(range(12))),
     n.pitch.number() if n.event_id in fixed or i==len(notes)-1 else None) for i,n in enumerate(notes))
   if not hasattr(harmony,'pitch_routes'):harmony.pitch_routes={}
   key=(first.pitch,contexts,id(library),register,harmony.profile)
@@ -175,6 +175,11 @@ def pitch_paths(first, contexts, library, register, profile=None):
   low,high=generator.fretboard.single_register((register[0]-7,register[1]+5))
   low, high = max(low, profile.register[0]), min(high, profile.register[1])
   result=[]
+  # Reattacks are an explicit primitive, separate from interval catalog paths
+  # (whose zero steps are deliberately excluded). Tied holds remain one event.
+  if all(first.number()%12 in allowed and (fixed is None or fixed==first.number())
+    for _,allowed,fixed in contexts):
+    result.append(((first,)*len(contexts),('primitive:repeated_attack',)))
   for path in paths:
     realized=[first]
     for (scale,allowed,fixed),step in zip(contexts[1:],path.steps):

generator/solo/scoring.py

@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 from __future__ import annotations
 
 import fractions
+import dataclasses
 
 import generator.solo.policy
 import generator.solo.types
@@ -116,3 +117,75 @@ def value(features):
 
 def feasible(plan, notes, choices, until):
   return Evaluation(plan, choices, until).feasible(notes)
+
+
+@dataclasses.dataclass(frozen=True)
+class MusicalEvaluation:
+  version: str
+  scope: tuple
+  valid: bool
+  pending: tuple
+  raw: dict
+  denominators: dict
+  weights: dict
+  contributions: dict
+  total: float
+  error: str = ''
+
+
+MUSICAL_WEIGHTS = {'rhythm':3., 'destination':2., 'harmony':2.,
+  'register':1., 'repetition':1., 'activity':1., 'difficulty':.5}
+
+
+def musical(plan, draft, notes, incoming, harmony, *, travel=0, weights=None, bar=None):
+  """The sole final evaluator of the active thematic composer.
+
+  Scores are normalized on complete sounding events, never notation fragments.
+  Contracts are validity requirements, not additional similarity rewards.
+  Retrieval estimates are deliberately not added to this result.
+  """
+  from generator.solo import drafts, groups, harmonic, phrasing, types
+  notes=types.sounding_notes(notes)
+  bar=getattr(harmony,'bar',fractions.Fraction(4)) if bar is None else bar
+  from generator import vocabulary
+  weights=dict(vocabulary.data('grammar').get('evaluation',{}).get('weights',MUSICAL_WEIGHTS) if weights is None else weights)
+  if set(weights)!=set(MUSICAL_WEIGHTS):raise ValueError('unknown or missing evaluation contribution')
+  checked=harmony.evaluate(notes, incoming.treatments, until=plan.end, complete=True,
+    enclosures=draft.enclosures, expressions=draft.expressions)
+  identity,identity_error=drafts.contract_valid(draft,notes)
+  anchors,anchor_error=harmonic.anchors_valid(draft.anchors,notes,plan.end,complete=True,closure=plan.closure)
+  feasible=Evaluation(plan,harmony.choices).feasible(notes)
+  valid=checked.valid and identity and anchors and feasible
+  error=checked.error or identity_error or anchor_error or ('' if feasible else 'activity intent not fulfilled')
+  span=float(plan.end-plan.start); sounded=sum(float(n.end-n.start) for n in notes)
+  islands=sum(a.end<b.start and b.end<c.start and b.end-b.start<=fractions.Fraction(1,2)
+    for a,b,c in zip(notes,notes[1:],notes[2:]))
+  # Rests at the edges can be entrance/release. Long internal gaps need a
+  # completed gesture, rather than receiving a universal occupancy penalty.
+  settled={a.hold_until for a in draft.anchors}
+  broken=sum(max(0,float(b.start-a.end)-1) for a,b in zip(notes,notes[1:])
+    if a.end not in settled and a.end-a.start<2)
+  entry=max(0,abs(notes[0].pitch.number()-incoming.last.pitch.number())-7)/12 if notes and incoming.last else 0.
+  rhythm=min(1.,islands/max(1,len(notes)-2)+broken/max(1,span)+entry/2)
+  # Explicit source groups retain their imported timing contract. Generated
+  # groups are checked before construction, not retroactively quantized here.
+  destinations=[]
+  for anchor in draft.anchors:
+    approach=[n for n in notes if n.start<anchor.earliest][-3:]
+    if approach:
+      distances=[abs(n.pitch.number()-anchor.pitch.number()) for n in approach]
+      # A broad approach may turn; large last-second jumps are a preference,
+      # not a nearest-note mandate for all intermediate events.
+      destinations.append(min(1,max(0,distances[-1]-5)/12))
+  goal=harmony.profile.reference
+  register=sum(float(n.end-n.start)*min(1,max(0,abs(n.pitch.number()-goal)-9)/12)
+    for n in notes)/max(sounded,.001) if goal is not None else 0.
+  history=phrasing.repetition(phrasing.heard(notes,draft.relationship),incoming.history,bar) if notes else 0.
+  activity=Evaluation(plan,harmony.choices).features(notes)['activity']
+  raw={'rhythm':rhythm,'destination':sum(destinations)/max(1,len(destinations)),
+    'harmony':checked.exposure,'register':register,'repetition':min(1,history),
+    'activity':activity,'difficulty':min(1,travel/max(1,len(notes))/2000)}
+  contributions={name:weights[name]*value for name,value in raw.items()}
+  return MusicalEvaluation('joint-musical-1',(plan.start,plan.end),valid,checked.pending,raw,
+    {'span':span,'sounding':sounded,'attacks':len(notes),'destinations':len(destinations)},weights,
+    contributions,sum(contributions.values()) if valid else float('inf'),error)

generator/solo/sequences.py

@@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ from __future__ import annotations
 import dataclasses
 import pathlib
 import types
+import functools
 
 import generator.solo.policy
 
@@ -13,6 +14,7 @@ import generator.musicxml
 class Sequence:
   id: str
   steps: tuple[int, ...]
+  @functools.lru_cache(maxsize=32768)
   def offsets(self) -> tuple[int, ...]:
     result = [0]
     for step in self.steps:
@@ -26,12 +28,14 @@ class Sequence:
 class Path:
   steps: tuple[int, ...]
   sources: tuple[str, ...]
+  @functools.lru_cache(maxsize=32768)
   def offsets(self):
     result = [0]
     for step in self.steps:
       result.append(result[-1] + step)
     return tuple(result)
 
+@functools.lru_cache(maxsize=32768)
 def family(steps):
   if not steps or all(s == 0 for s in steps):
     return 'repeated'
@@ -47,14 +51,19 @@ def family(steps):
 def diverse(items, rank, category, limit):
   """Round-robin eligible musical families before a destructive cutoff."""
   groups = {}
-  for item in sorted(items, key=rank):
-    groups.setdefault(category(item), []).append(item)
+  # Rank once: hashing full event provenance and classifying interval paths
+  # used to be repeated for every retained layer. Preserve stable tie order.
+  decorated = sorted(((rank(item), i, item) for i,item in enumerate(items)),key=lambda v:v[:2])
+  for value in decorated:
+    groups.setdefault(category(value[2]), []).append(value)
   result, index = [], 0
   while len(result) < limit:
     layer = [values[index] for values in groups.values() if len(values) > index]
     if not layer:
       break
-    result.extend(sorted(layer, key=rank)[:limit - len(result)])
+    # Equal ranks retain category insertion order, just as the original stable
+    # layer sort did; the input index is only for the initial sort.
+    result.extend(v[2] for v in sorted(layer,key=lambda v:v[0])[:limit-len(result)])
     index += 1
   return tuple(result)
 

generator/solo/themes.py

@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ from fractions import Fraction as F
 import generator.model
 import generator.harmony
 import generator.vocabulary
-from generator.solo import types, policy, sequences, routes, features as references, similarity, phrasing, profiles
+from generator.solo import types, policy, sequences, routes, features as references, similarity, phrasing, profiles, groups as rhythm_groups
 
 
 def source_notes(analysis):
@@ -71,13 +71,16 @@ def seeds(analysis, bar, seed):
         identity=policy.stable_rank(seed,(group,treatment))[:12]
         groups.append(types.SourceReference(identity,parent,group[0].start,group[-1].end,local,treatment))
   def rank(ref):
-    rhythm={(n.start,n.end-n.start) for n in ref.notes}
+    rhythm=set(rhythm_groups.signature(ref.notes))
     intervals={b.pitch.number()-a.pitch.number() for a,b in zip(ref.notes,ref.notes[1:])}
     preferred=generator.vocabulary.role().get('preferred_features',[])
     preference=preferred.index(ref.treatment) if ref.treatment in preferred else 0
     turn=any(a*b<0 for a,b in zip(ref.notes and tuple(b.pitch.number()-a.pitch.number() for a,b in zip(ref.notes,ref.notes[1:])),tuple(b.pitch.number()-a.pitch.number() for a,b in zip(ref.notes,ref.notes[1:]))[1:]))
     return (-min(4,len(intervals))-.3*turn+.15*preference,-min(3,len(rhythm)),ref.id)
-  return sequences.diverse(groups,rank,lambda r:(r.treatment,int(max(0,r.start)//(4*bar))),policy.DEFAULT.theme_seed_limit)
+  # Preserve different contracts first. Combining treatment with form position
+  # created many categories of the preferred treatment and could crowd every
+  # rhythm/contour seed out before a single pitch was constructed.
+  return sequences.diverse(groups,rank,lambda r:r.treatment,policy.DEFAULT.theme_seed_limit)
 
 
 def feature(reference, actual, *, treatment=None):
@@ -87,7 +90,7 @@ def feature(reference, actual, *, treatment=None):
     'repeat_with_harmonic_adaptation':('rhythm','contour'),'answer':('contour',),
     'extend':('contour',),'fragment':('rhythm',),'callback':('rhythm','pitches'),
     'return':('rhythm','intervals'), 'develop_rhythm':('rhythm',),
-    'develop_contour':('intervals',), 'continue':('contour',)}[treatment]
+    'develop_contour':('intervals',), 'continue':(), 'connect':(), 'extension':('contour',)}[treatment]
   original=reference.notes
   authored=next((r for r in generator.vocabulary.data('grammar')['transformations'] if r['id']==treatment),None)
   if authored:required=tuple(authored['preserve'])
@@ -103,7 +106,7 @@ def rhythmic_purpose(operation, terminal=False):
   if terminal:return 'arrival'
   if operation in ('introduce','callback','return','repeat_with_harmonic_adaptation'):return 'entrance'
   if operation in ('answer','fragment'):return 'answer'
-  return 'connect' if operation=='continue' else 'continue'
+  return 'connect' if operation in ('continue','connect') else 'continue'
 
 
 def rhythm_cost(pattern,length,purpose):
@@ -145,12 +148,12 @@ def rhythm_windows(library,meter,length,context,purpose='continue'):
       for offset in sorted({F(),*(a for a,_ in pattern)}):
         if offset+length>total or any(a<offset<b or a<offset+length<b for a,b in pattern):continue
         selected=tuple((a-offset,b-offset) for a,b in pattern if offset<=a and b<=offset+length)
-        if selected and len(selected)<=16:patterns.setdefault(selected,identifier)
+        if selected and len(selected)<=16 and rhythm_groups.valid(selected):patterns.setdefault(selected,identifier)
     # Authored cells can start late and continue over computational barlines.
     for cell in generator.vocabulary.rhythm_cells(tempo,purpose):
       identifier,pattern,total=cell.id,cell.pattern,cell.duration
       if total>length:continue
-      for offset in (F(),F(1,2),max(F(),length-total)):
+      for offset in ((F(),) if cell.entry=='pickup' else (F(),F(1,2),max(F(),length-total))):
         if offset+total>length:continue
         head=tuple((a+offset,b+offset) for a,b in pattern)
         # Keep representative compatible continuations; never let dictionary
@@ -159,8 +162,10 @@ def rhythm_windows(library,meter,length,context,purpose='continue'):
           lambda p:(len(p),p[-1][1]-p[-1][0]),2) or ((),)
         for tail in tails:
           if any(a<offset+total<b for a,b in tail):continue
-          combined=(*head,*((a,b) for a,b in tail if a>=offset+total))
-          if 2<=len(combined)<=16:patterns.setdefault(combined,'authored:'+identifier)
+          continuation=tuple((a,b) for a,b in tail if a>=offset+total)
+          if cell.exit=='continue' and offset+total<length and (not continuation or continuation[0][0]!=offset+total):continue
+          combined=(*head,*continuation)
+          if 2<=len(combined)<=16 and rhythm_groups.valid(combined):patterns.setdefault(combined,'authored:'+identifier)
     context.pools[key]=sequences.diverse(tuple(patterns.items()),
       lambda x:(rhythm_cost(x[0],length,purpose)+(0 if x[1].startswith('authored:') else .05),policy.stable_rank('rhythm-window',x[0])),
       lambda x:(x[1].startswith('authored:'),len(x[0]),x[0][0][0],any(a[1]!=b[0] for a,b in zip(x[0],x[0][1:]))),8)
@@ -193,7 +198,7 @@ def patterns(ref, start, finish, rhythms, meter, context, *, home=None, operatio
         if b-a==1:
           values[(*original[:i],(a,a+F(1,2)),(a+F(1,2),b),*original[i+1:])]=label+'; diminution'
       for i,((a,b),(c,d)) in enumerate(zip(original,original[1:])):
-        if b!=c:continue
+        if b!=c or any((v*2).denominator!=1 for v in (a,b,c,d)):continue
         for split in (a+F(1,2),a+F(3,2),d-F(1,2)):
           if a<split<d:
             values[(*original[:i],(a,split),(split,d),*original[i+2:])]=label+'; rhythmic alteration'
@@ -201,10 +206,12 @@ def patterns(ref, start, finish, rhythms, meter, context, *, home=None, operatio
     arrivals={}
     arrival=ending.earliest-start
     for original,label in values.items():
-      head=tuple((a,min(b,arrival)) for a,b in original if a<arrival)
-      if len(head)>=len(ref.notes):
-        arrivals[(*head,(arrival,ending.hold_until-start))]=label+'; planned sustained close'
+      try: revised=rhythm_groups.broaden(original,arrival,ending.hold_until-start)
+      except ValueError: revised=()
+      if revised and len(revised)>=len(ref.notes):
+        arrivals[revised]=label+'; planned sounding destination'
     values=arrivals
+  values={p:label for p,label in values.items() if rhythm_groups.valid(p) or fixed_rhythm and p==prefix}
   return sequences.diverse(tuple(values.items()),lambda x:(rhythm_cost(x[0],length,purpose),policy.stable_rank(ref.id,x[0])),
     lambda x:(len(x[0]),tuple(b-a for a,b in x[0][:3]),x[0][0][0]),policy.DEFAULT.theme_rhythm_alternatives)
 
@@ -233,61 +240,6 @@ def relative_steps(notes,harmony):
   return tuple(result)
 
 
-def instantiate(templates,first,steps,harmony):
-  result=[dataclasses.replace(templates[0],pitch=first)]
-  for note,step in zip(templates[1:],steps):
-    span=harmony.at(note.start)
-    if not span or not span.scale:return ()
-    options=routes.advance(span.scale,result[-1].pitch.number(),step)
-    if not options:return ()
-    p=options[0]
-    if not harmony.profile.permits(p.number()) or p.number()%12 not in types.permitted(harmony.choices,note.start,note.end):return ()
-    result.append(dataclasses.replace(note,pitch=p))
-  return tuple(result) if len(result)==len(templates) else ()
-
-
-def prefix_paths(templates,ref,first,harmony,library):
-  if not hasattr(harmony,'theme_prefixes'):harmony.theme_prefixes={}
-  key=(templates[:len(ref.notes)],ref,first,id(library))
-  if key not in harmony.theme_prefixes:
-    harmony.theme_prefixes[key]=_prefix_paths(templates,ref,first,harmony,library)
-  return harmony.theme_prefixes[key]
-
-
-def _prefix_paths(templates,ref,first,harmony,library):
-  count=len(ref.notes); original=ref.notes
-  if count==1:return ((dataclasses.replace(templates[0],pitch=first),),)
-  if ref.treatment in ('opening_fragment','characteristic_interval','callback'):
-    delta=first.number()-original[0].pitch.number()
-    if ref.treatment in ('opening_fragment','callback') and delta%12:return ()
-    result=[]
-    from generator.solo.leads import available
-    for template,n in zip(templates,original):
-      target=n.pitch.number()+delta
-      p=next((p for p in available(harmony,template.start,template.end,members=template.end-template.start>=2) if p.number()==target),None)
-      if p is None:return ()
-      result.append(dataclasses.replace(template,pitch=p))
-    return (tuple(result),)
-  paths=[]
-  if ref.treatment == 'return':
-    from generator.solo.leads import available
-    delta=first.number()-original[0].pitch.number()
-    direct=[]
-    for template,n in zip(templates,original):
-      p=next((p for p in available(harmony,template.start,template.end,members=template.end-template.start>=2) if p.number()==n.pitch.number()+delta),None)
-      if p is None: break
-      direct.append(dataclasses.replace(template,pitch=p))
-    if len(direct)==count: paths.append(tuple(direct))
-  end_template=templates[count-1]
-  source_motion=original[-1].pitch.number()-original[0].pitch.number()
-  for target in pitches(harmony,end_template,first.number()+source_motion,limit=4):
-    template=tuple(dataclasses.replace(n,pitch=first if i==0 else target) for i,n in enumerate(templates[:count]))
-    paths.extend(r.notes for r in routes.candidates(template,{template[-1].event_id},harmony,library,harmony.profile.register,'seed '+ref.id,purpose='entrance'))
-  valid=[p for p in paths if not references.feature_error(feature(ref,p),p)]
-  return sequences.diverse(valid,lambda ns:(routes.path_cost(ns),policy.stable_rank(ref.id,ns)),
-    lambda ns:routes.path_family(ns,harmony),4)
-
-
 @dataclasses.dataclass(frozen=True)
 class Unit:
   notes: tuple[types.Note,...]
@@ -303,81 +255,86 @@ class Unit:
 
 
 def unit_candidates(ref,start,finish,incoming,harmony,library,rhythms,meter,context,*,home=None,operation='introduce',terminal=False,batch=0,ending=None,goal=None):
-  # History is evaluated by the caller after retrieving these concrete options.
-  # Every state component used to construct this pool is in its cache key.
-  if not hasattr(harmony,'fingerprint'):harmony.fingerprint=policy.stable_rank('harmony',(harmony.choices,harmony.profile))
-  key=('theme-unit',ref,start,finish,incoming.last,incoming.direction,incoming.treatments,incoming.history,home,operation,ending,goal,batch,harmony.fingerprint,id(library),id(rhythms),policy.DEFAULT)
+  """Joint whole-gesture pitch/rhythm actions, conditioned on the actual entry.
+
+  A complete route is proposed before thematic evidence is checked. No motif
+  prefix is spliced to an independently cheapest suffix. Ordinary search ends
+  carry no chord-tone obligation; long-note and destination contracts still do.
+  """
+  from generator.solo import leads
+  key=('joint-gesture-1',ref,start,finish,incoming.last,incoming.direction,incoming.treatments,
+    home,operation,ending,goal,batch,id(harmony),id(library),id(rhythms))
   if key in context.results:
     context.diagnostics['cache_hits']+=1;return context.results[key]
-  result=[]; count=len(ref.notes)
+  trace=context.diagnostics.setdefault('operations',{}).setdefault(operation,
+    dict(eligible=0,proposed=0,valid=0,retained=0,jobs=0,pruned_jobs=0,rejected_by_rule=0))
+  trace['eligible']+=1
+  require_feature=operation not in ('continue','connect')
+  count=len(ref.notes) if require_feature else 0
   jobs=[]
   for pattern,label in patterns(ref,start,finish,rhythms,meter,context,home=home,operation=operation,terminal=terminal,ending=ending):
-    if len(pattern)<count or len(pattern)>16:continue
-    templates=tuple(types.Note(start+a,start+b,ref.notes[0].pitch,tuple(s for n in ref.notes for s in n.sources),
-      'theme',event_id=f'{ref.id}:{start}:{i}') for i,(a,b) in enumerate(pattern))
-    base=incoming.last.pitch.number() if incoming.last else harmony.profile.reference if harmony.profile.reference is not None else ref.notes[0].pitch.number()
-    firsts=pitches(harmony,templates[0],base,limit=6 if batch else 3)
-    targets=(ending.pitch,) if ending else pitches(harmony,templates[-1],goal if goal is not None else base,members=True,limit=policy.DEFAULT.theme_destinations,incoming=incoming)
+    if len(pattern)<max(2,count) or len(pattern)>16:continue
+    provenance=tuple(dict.fromkeys(s for n in ref.notes for s in n.sources))
+    templates=tuple(types.Note(start+a,start+b,ref.notes[0].pitch,provenance,
+      'theme' if require_feature else 'connection',event_id=f'{ref.id}:{operation}:{start}:{i}') for i,(a,b) in enumerate(pattern))
+    base=incoming.last.pitch.number() if incoming.last else harmony.profile.reference or ref.notes[0].pitch.number()
+    firsts=pitches(harmony,templates[0],base,limit=6)
+    if incoming.last is None:
+      offsets=generator.vocabulary.role().get('register_alternatives',[-7,0,7])
+      firsts=tuple(dict.fromkeys(p for offset in offsets for p in pitches(harmony,templates[0],base+offset,limit=2)))
+    targets=(ending.pitch,) if ending else pitches(harmony,templates[-1],goal if goal is not None else base,
+      members=False,limit=policy.DEFAULT.theme_destinations,incoming=incoming)
     for first in firsts:
       for target in targets:
-        # Rank joint jobs, retaining rhythm and destination coverage before
-        # expensive path instantiation. The budget is spent on complete routes.
-        rank=harmony.profile.cost(first.number())+max(0,abs(first.number()-base)-5)/12+phrasing.destination_cost(target,templates[-1].start,templates[-1].end,harmony,incoming,goal if goal is not None else base,terminal)
+        motion=ref.notes[-1].pitch.number()-ref.notes[0].pitch.number()
+        if operation=='answer':motion=-motion
+        # Rank purposeful direction separately from entry continuity. No reward
+        # for minimizing every interval or for repeatedly visiting the midpoint.
+        rank=max(0,abs(first.number()-base)-7)/12
+        rank+=.1*min(1,abs((target.number()-first.number())-motion)/12)
         jobs.append((rank,templates,label,first,target))
-  jobs.sort(key=lambda j:(j[0],policy.stable_rank(ref.id,(j[1],j[3],j[4]))))
-  selected=[];rhythm_seen=set();target_seen=set();entry_seen=set();degrees_seen=set()
-  for job in jobs:
-    family=phrasing.destination_family(job[4],job[1][-1].start,harmony)
-    if family not in degrees_seen:
-      selected.append(job);degrees_seen.add(family)
-  for job in jobs:
-    rhythm=tuple((n.start,n.end) for n in job[1]);target=job[4].number();entry=job[3].number()
-    if rhythm not in rhythm_seen or target not in target_seen or entry not in entry_seen:
-      if job not in selected:selected.append(job)
-      rhythm_seen.add(rhythm);target_seen.add(target);entry_seen.add(entry)
-  job_limit=policy.DEFAULT.theme_route_jobs*(batch+1)
-  for job in jobs:
-    if len(selected)>=job_limit:break
-    if job not in selected:selected.append(job)
-  for _,templates,label,first,target in selected[:job_limit]:
-      proposed=[]
-      if home and operation in ('repeat_with_harmonic_adaptation','return') and len(templates)==len(home.notes):
-        heard=instantiate(templates,first,home.degree_steps,harmony)
-        if heard and heard[-1].pitch==target:proposed.append((heard,()))
-      for prefix in prefix_paths(templates,ref,first,harmony,library)[:2+batch]:
-        if len(prefix)==len(templates):
-          if prefix[-1].pitch==target:proposed.append((prefix,()))
-          continue
-        tail=(prefix[-1],*templates[count:])
-        tail=(*tail[:-1],dataclasses.replace(tail[-1],pitch=target))
-        for route in routes.candidates(tail,{tail[-1].event_id},harmony,library,harmony.profile.register,operation+' '+ref.id,purpose=rhythmic_purpose(operation,terminal))[:3+batch]:
-          proposed.append(((*prefix[:-1],*route.notes),(route,)))
-      seen=set()
-      for actual,connections in proposed:
-        identity=tuple(n.pitch.number() for n in actual)
-        if identity in seen:continue
-        seen.add(identity)
-        core=actual[:count]; contract=feature(ref,core,treatment=operation if operation!='introduce' else None)
-        if references.feature_error(contract,actual):continue
-        last=actual[-1]
-        if last.pitch.number()%12 not in harmony.members(last.start,last.end):continue
-        checked=harmony.evaluate(actual,until=finish,complete=True)
-        if not checked.valid:continue
-        entry=max(0,abs(first.number()-incoming.last.pitch.number())-5)/12 if incoming.last else 0.
-        leaps=sum(max(0,abs(b.pitch.number()-a.pitch.number())-5)/12 for a,b in zip(actual,actual[1:]))/max(1,len(actual)-1)
-        direction=min(1,abs(last.pitch.number()-goal)/12) if goal is not None else 0.
-        # Activity belongs to the complete phrase; contracts are pass/fail.
-        score=harmony.profile.cost(profiles.weighted_center(actual))+2*checked.exposure+entry+leaps+phrasing.destination_cost(last.pitch,last.start,last.end,harmony,incoming,goal,terminal)
-        anchor=ending or types.Anchor(last.event_id+':arrival',last.start,last.start,last.pitch,harmony.members(last.start,last.end),harmony.profile.register,
-          last.end-last.start,'intermediate',harmony.at(last.start).chord,hold_until=last.end)
-        score+=.25*rhythm_cost(tuple((n.start-start,n.end-start) for n in actual),finish-start,rhythmic_purpose(operation,terminal))
-        result.append(Unit(actual,contract,ref,operation,anchor,score,label,connections,start,finish))
+  selected=sequences.diverse(jobs,lambda j:(j[0],policy.stable_rank(ref.id,(j[1],j[3],j[4]))),
+    lambda j:(tuple(n.end-n.start for n in j[1]),j[3].number()//12,
+      (j[4].number()>j[3].number())-(j[4].number()<j[3].number())),policy.DEFAULT.theme_route_jobs*(batch+1))
+  trace['jobs']+=len(jobs);trace['pruned_jobs']+=len(jobs)-len(selected)
+  result=[]
+  for _,templates,label,first,target in selected:
+    timed=(dataclasses.replace(templates[0],pitch=first),*templates[1:-1],dataclasses.replace(templates[-1],pitch=target))
+    proposed=list(routes.candidates(timed,{timed[-1].event_id},harmony,library,harmony.profile.register,
+      operation+' '+ref.id,purpose=rhythmic_purpose(operation,terminal)))
+    # A substantial literal return is a musical action, not merely the hope
+    # that a general interval search will accidentally reproduce the theme.
+    if require_feature and len(templates)==len(ref.notes):
+      delta=first.number()-ref.notes[0].pitch.number()
+      actual=[]
+      for template,n in zip(templates,ref.notes):
+        options=leads.available(harmony,template.start,template.end,members=template.end-template.start>=2)
+        p=next((p for p in options if p.number()==n.pitch.number()+delta),None)
+        if p is None:break
+        actual.append(dataclasses.replace(template,pitch=p))
+      if len(actual)==len(templates) and actual[-1].pitch==target:
+        proposed.append(types.RouteCandidate('theme:'+ref.id,tuple(actual),actual[-1],(),operation,(ref.id,)))
+    for route in proposed:
+      trace['proposed']+=1
+      actual=route.notes
+      contract=feature(ref,actual[:count],treatment=operation if operation!='introduce' else None) if count else None
+      if contract and references.feature_error(contract,actual):
+        trace['rejected_by_rule']+=1;continue
+      checked=harmony.evaluate(actual,until=finish,complete=True)
+      if not checked.valid:trace['rejected_by_rule']+=1;continue
+      trace['valid']+=1
+      entry=max(0,abs(first.number()-incoming.last.pitch.number())-7)/12 if incoming.last else 0.
+      score=2*checked.exposure+entry+.1*routes.path_cost(actual)
+      score+=.25*rhythm_cost(tuple((n.start-start,n.end-start) for n in actual),finish-start,rhythmic_purpose(operation,terminal))
+      result.append(Unit(actual,contract,ref,operation,ending,score,label,(route,),start,finish))
   unique={tuple((n.start,n.end,n.pitch) for n in u.notes):u for u in result}
-  selected=sequences.diverse(tuple(unique.values()),lambda u:(u.score,policy.stable_rank(ref.id,u.notes)),
-    lambda u:(u.notes[0].pitch.number()//12,u.notes[-1].pitch.number(),tuple(n.end-n.start for n in u.notes[:count])),policy.DEFAULT.theme_unit_alternatives)
-  context.diagnostics['generated_candidates']+=len(selected)
-  context.results[key]=selected
-  return selected
+  chosen=sequences.diverse(tuple(unique.values()),lambda u:(u.score,policy.stable_rank(ref.id,u.notes)),
+    lambda u:(routes.path_family(u.notes,harmony),u.notes[0].pitch.number()//12,
+      tuple(n.end-n.start for n in u.notes)),policy.DEFAULT.theme_unit_alternatives)
+  trace['retained']+=len(chosen)
+  context.diagnostics['generated_candidates']+=len(chosen)
+  context.results[key]=chosen
+  return chosen
 
 
 def home_reference(home,operation):
@@ -400,6 +357,18 @@ def make_home(unit,harmony,start=None,end=None):
   return dataclasses.replace(home,degree_steps=relative_steps(unit.notes,harmony),signature=home.notes[:len(unit.reference.notes)])
 
 
+def operation_choices(home,incoming,cursor,phrase_start,closing):
+  available=generator.vocabulary.data('grammar')['operations']
+  selected=[]
+  for rule in available:
+    op=rule['id']
+    if rule.get('entry_only') and cursor!=phrase_start:continue
+    if rule.get('after_statement') and not home:continue
+    if rule.get('needs_recent') and not incoming.notes:continue
+    selected.append(op)
+  return tuple(selected)
+
+
 def unit_end(source,cursor,home,ending,bar):
   """Bound search by time without cutting the heard signature at a barline."""
   length=2*bar
@@ -409,7 +378,7 @@ def unit_end(source,cursor,home,ending,bar):
       length+=home.signature[-1].end
     length=min(2*bar,max(bar,length))
   finish=min(source.end,cursor+length)
-  if source.end-finish<bar+2 or ending.earliest<finish:
+  if source.end-finish<bar+2 or ending and ending.earliest<finish:
     finish=source.end
   return finish
 
@@ -424,7 +393,8 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
   seed_key=('source-seeds',analysis,bar,seed)
   if seed_key not in context.pools:context.pools[seed_key]=seeds(analysis,bar,seed)
   roots=context.pools[seed_key]
-  ending_options=phrasing.endings(source,incoming,part,harmony,bar,limit=8*(batch+1),final=final)
+  ending_options=phrasing.endings(source,incoming,part,harmony,bar,limit=6*(batch+1),final=final)
+  if not final:ending_options=(None,*ending_options)
   states=[(0.,(),incoming.home,incoming,ending) for ending in ending_options]
   while states and any(not units or units[-1].end<source.end for _,units,_,_,_ in states):
     next_states=[]
@@ -438,15 +408,12 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
       if introducing:
         requests=[(r,'introduce') for r in roots]
       else:
-        operations=['continue'] if finish==source.end and cursor>source.start else ['develop_contour','develop_rhythm']
-        if cursor==source.start:operations.append('return')
+        operations=operation_choices(home,state,cursor,source.start,finish==source.end)
         requests=[(home_reference(home,op),op) for op in operations]
         # A uniform duration alone is not identifying musical evidence.
         requests=[(r,op) for r,op in requests if op!='develop_rhythm' or len({n.end-n.start for n in r.notes})>1 or any(a.end!=b.start for a,b in zip(r.notes,r.notes[1:]))]
-        if cursor>=8*bar and cursor==source.start and incoming.callbacks<2:
-          requests.extend((dataclasses.replace(r,treatment='callback'),'callback') for r in roots[:1] if r.end-r.start<=bar)
       for ref,operation in requests:
-        if introducing and source.end-source.start<2*bar and ending.earliest-cursor<ref.notes[-1].end:
+        if introducing and ending and source.end-source.start<2*bar and ending.earliest-cursor<ref.notes[-1].end:
           # A missing-harmony boundary can leave less than one full statement.
           # Declare a smaller contour seed; never pretend it proves the full motif.
           count=min(3,int(2*(ending.earliest-cursor)),len(ref.notes))
@@ -465,9 +432,10 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
           if len(reduced)<2:continue
           ref=dataclasses.replace(ref,notes=reduced,treatment='contour_seed')
           operation='continue'
-        terminal=finish==source.end
+        terminal=bool(ending and finish==source.end)
         base=state.last.pitch.number() if state.last else ref.notes[0].pitch.number()
-        goal=ending.pitch.number() if terminal else round(base+(ending.pitch.number()-base)*float((finish-cursor)/(source.end-cursor)))
+        destination=ending.pitch.number() if ending else phrasing.register_goal(state,part,base,harmony.profile)
+        goal=destination if finish==source.end else round(base+(destination-base)*float((finish-cursor)/(source.end-cursor)))
         options=unit_candidates(ref,cursor,finish,state,harmony,library,rhythms,meter,context,home=home,operation=operation,
           terminal=terminal,batch=batch,ending=ending if terminal else None,goal=goal)
         for unit in options:
@@ -487,22 +455,19 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
       elapsed=units[-1].end-source.start
       return cost/max(.001,float(elapsed)),policy.stable_rank(seed,tuple(u.notes for u in units))
     states=sequences.diverse(next_states,rank,
-      lambda v:(v[2].id,v[4].pitch.number(),v[4].duration,len(v[1][-1].notes),v[1][-1].operation),policy.DEFAULT.theme_continuations)
+      lambda v:(v[2].id,(v[4].pitch.number(),v[4].duration) if v[4] else 'open',len(v[1][-1].notes),v[1][-1].operation),policy.DEFAULT.theme_continuations)
     if not states:return ()
   result=[]
   for cost,units,home,state,ending in states:
     plain=tuple(n for u in units for n in u.notes)
     if similarity.near_copy(plain,head,source.start,source.end)['near_copy']:
       context.diagnostics['near_copy_rejections']=context.diagnostics.get('near_copy_rejections',0)+1;continue
-    features=tuple(u.feature for u in units)
+    features=tuple(u.feature for u in units if u.feature)
     # Cell tails are not compulsory melodic arrivals. Only the selected close
     # has a sounding contract; intermediate turns remain editable.
-    anchors=(ending,)
-    tails=(types.SustainedTail(ending.earliest,ending.hold_until,ending.pitch.number()),)
+    anchors=(ending,) if ending else ()
+    tails=(types.SustainedTail(ending.earliest,ending.hold_until,ending.pitch.number()),) if ending else ()
     options=[(plain,(),())]
-    if stage=='elaborated':
-      for actual,edit,route in leads.elaborate(plain,features,harmony,library,rhythms,meter,source,sustain_entry=True,tails=tails):
-        options.append((actual,(edit,),(route,)))
     for notes,edits,selected_routes in options:
       identifier=part+'_'+source.id+'_'+policy.stable_rank(seed,leads.signature(notes))[:12]
       transforms=tuple(types.Transformation(identifier+f':{i}',u.reference.id,home.id,u.operation,u.notes[0].start,u.notes[-1].end,
@@ -512,9 +477,11 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
         features=features,reference=source_ref.id,reference_motif=home,source_phrase=source,source_reference=source_ref,
         source_links=tuple((n.event_id,n.sources) for n in notes),sustained_tails=tails)
       motif=types.Motif(home.id,home.notes,home.duration,(), 'realized solo theme from '+source_ref.id)
-      landmark=types.Landmark(ending.earliest,ending.latest,ending.pitch.number(),ending.pitch.number(),0,'sustained destination')
+      landmarks=(types.Landmark(ending.earliest,ending.latest,ending.pitch.number(),ending.pitch.number(),0,'sounding destination'),) if ending else ()
+      closed=bool(ending and ending.role=='terminal')
       plan=types.PhrasePlan(identifier,source.start,source.end,motif,draft.relationship,'thematic_recomposition',None,harmony.profile.register,F(5,4),
-        source.end-ending.hold_until,phrasing.activity(source,ending),(landmark,), 'sustain','closed',seed,
+        source.end-ending.hold_until if ending else F(),phrasing.activity(source,ending),landmarks,
+        'sustain' if ending else 'connected','closed' if closed else 'open',seed,
         source.id,source.start,source.end,(anchors,))
       before_rhythm=draft
       from generator.solo import gesture_rhythm
@@ -523,20 +490,12 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
         notes=draft.notes;edits=(*edits,*rhythm_edits);transforms=draft.transformations
       phrase=realization.checked_phrase(plan,draft,notes,incoming.treatments,incoming,harmony,tempo,edits)
       if phrase is None:continue
-      score=phrasing.evaluate(notes,incoming,harmony,source.start,source.end,bar)+.1*gesture_rhythm.fragmentation(notes)
-      score+=sum(phrasing.destination_cost(u.anchor.pitch,u.anchor.earliest,u.anchor.hold_until,harmony,incoming,phrasing.register_goal(incoming,part,u.notes[0].pitch.number(),harmony.profile),u.anchor.role=='terminal') for u in units)/len(units)
-      appearance_state=incoming
-      for unit in units:
-        score+=phrasing.appearance_cost(unit.operation,appearance_state,unit.notes[0].start,solo_end)/len(units)
-        if unit.operation=='return':
-          appearance_state=dataclasses.replace(appearance_state,returns=(*appearance_state.returns,unit.notes[0].start))
-      score+=.05*phrase.state.travel/max(1,len(notes))/2000
       history=incoming.history
       for transform in transforms:
         group=tuple(n for n in notes if n.event_id in transform.events)
-        if group:history=phrasing.remember(history,phrasing.heard(group,transform.operation,ending if group[-1].end==ending.hold_until else None,bar),bar)
-      current=dataclasses.replace(phrase.state,next_destination=phrasing.next_destination(ending,harmony),home=home,source_reference=source_ref,callbacks=incoming.callbacks+sum(u.operation=='callback' for u in units),
-        history=history,returns=state.returns,closures=incoming.closures+1,register_peak=max(state.register_peak,*(n.pitch.number() for n in notes)))
+        if group:history=phrasing.remember(history,phrasing.heard(group,transform.operation,ending if ending and group[-1].end==ending.hold_until else None,bar),bar)
+      current=dataclasses.replace(phrase.state,next_destination=phrasing.next_destination(ending,harmony) if ending else incoming.next_destination,home=home,source_reference=source_ref,callbacks=incoming.callbacks+sum(u.operation=='callback' for u in units),
+        history=history,returns=state.returns,closures=incoming.closures+int(closed),register_peak=max(state.register_peak,*(n.pitch.number() for n in notes)))
       if not incoming.home:
         introduced=tuple(n for n in notes if n.start<units[0].notes[-1].end)
         heard=dataclasses.replace(home,notes=tuple(dataclasses.replace(n,start=n.start-source.start,end=n.end-source.start,position=None) for n in introduced),
@@ -545,6 +504,30 @@ def phrase_candidates(source,analysis,incoming,part,harmony,library,rhythms,mete
       source_control=leads.shift(source.notes,next((o for o in (0,1,-1,2,-2) if all(41<=n.pitch.number()+12*o<=76 for n in source.notes)),0))
       original=dataclasses.replace(draft,id=identifier+':source',notes=source_control,features=(),anchors=(),structural=(),sustained_tails=())
       refined=dataclasses.replace(draft,id=identifier+':plain',notes=plain)
-      result.append(dataclasses.replace(phrase,score=score,state=current,initial=original,refined=refined,before_rhythm=before_rhythm,routes=(*tuple(r for u in units for r in u.routes if all(any((n.event_id,n.start,n.end,n.pitch)==(a.event_id,a.start,a.end,a.pitch) for a in notes) for n in r.notes)),*selected_routes)))
-  return sequences.diverse(result,lambda p:(p.score,policy.stable_rank(seed,p.draft.id)),
-    lambda p:(p.state.home.id,p.state.last.pitch.number(),p.anchors[-1].duration,len(p.state.returns)),policy.DEFAULT.phrase_alternatives)
+      result.append(dataclasses.replace(phrase,state=current,initial=original,refined=refined,before_rhythm=before_rhythm,routes=(*tuple(r for u in units for r in u.routes if all(any((n.event_id,n.start,n.end,n.pitch)==(a.event_id,a.start,a.end,a.pitch) for a in notes) for n in r.notes)),*selected_routes)))
+  from generator.solo import expressions,gesture_rhythm
+  if stage=='elaborated':
+    revisions=[]
+    for base in result:
+      for changed,edit,route in gesture_rhythm.join_variants(base.draft,harmony,library):
+        revised=realization.checked_phrase(base.plan,changed,changed.notes,incoming.treatments,incoming,harmony,tempo,(*base.edits,edit))
+        if revised is None:continue
+        state=dataclasses.replace(base.state,notes=revised.state.notes,last=revised.state.last,
+          motifs=revised.state.motifs,travel=revised.state.travel)
+        history=incoming.history
+        for t in changed.transformations:
+          heard=tuple(n for n in changed.notes if n.event_id in t.events)
+          if heard:history=phrasing.remember(history,phrasing.heard(heard,t.operation,bar=bar),bar)
+        state=dataclasses.replace(state,history=history)
+        retained=tuple(r for r in base.routes if not any(n.start<edit.end and n.end>edit.start for n in r.notes))
+        revisions.append(dataclasses.replace(revised,state=state,initial=base.initial,refined=base.refined,
+          before_rhythm=base.draft,routes=(*retained,route)))
+    context.diagnostics['join_revision_candidates']=context.diagnostics.get('join_revision_candidates',0)+len(revisions)
+    result.extend(revisions)
+  if stage=='elaborated' and getattr(context,'expressions_enabled',True):
+    result=expressions.joint_candidates(result,incoming,harmony,tempo,context,bar=bar)
+  selected=sequences.diverse(result,lambda p:(p.score,policy.stable_rank(seed,p.draft.id)),
+    lambda p:(p.state.home.id,p.plan.closure,p.state.last.pitch.number(),tuple(e.kind for e in p.draft.expressions)),policy.DEFAULT.phrase_alternatives)
+  context.diagnostics.setdefault('evaluations',[]).extend(
+    {'id':p.draft.id,'retained':p in selected,'evaluation':dataclasses.asdict(p.evaluation)} for p in sorted(result,key=lambda p:p.score)[:12] if p.evaluation)
+  return selected

generator/solo/types.py

@@ -361,6 +361,8 @@ class Phrase:
   routes: tuple[RouteCandidate, ...] = ()
   before_enclosure: MelodicDraft | None = None
   before_rhythm: MelodicDraft | None = None
+  evaluation: object | None = None
+  rhythm_groups: tuple = ()
 
 @dataclasses.dataclass(frozen=True)
 class Solo: